02 824 371
Antidotia
Antidotia
Antidotia

Station  K
The Traditional Subtraction Algorithm 

How does this dots-and-boxes approach compare with the standard algorithm for subtraction?

Question 1

Consider again 512347512 - 347.

I4S10-image22

The standard algorithm has you start at the right to first look at “22 take away 77,” which you can’t do. (Well you can do it, it is 5-5, but you are not to write that for this algorithm.)

So what do you do?

You “borrow one.” That is, you take a dot from the tens column and unexplode it to make ten ones. That leaves zero dots in the tens column. We should write ten ones to go with the two in the ones column.

I4SK-image61

But we are a bit clever here and just write 1212 rather than 10+210 + 2. (That is, we put a 11 in front of the 22 to make it look like twelve.)

I4SK-image65

Then we say “twelve take seven is five” and write that answer.

I4SK-image66

The rightmost column is complete. Shift now to the middle column.

We see “zero take away four,” which can’t be done. So perform another unexplosion, that is, another “borrow,” to see 10410 - 4 in that column. We write the answer 66.

We then move to the last remaining column where we have 434 - 3, which is 11.

I4SK-image71

Phew!

Question 2

Here are a few questions for you to try, if you like.

Compute each of the following two ways: the dots-and-boxes way (and fixing the answer for society to read) and then with the traditional algorithm. The answers should be the same.

Thinking question along the way: As you fix up your answers for society, does it seem easier to unexplode from left to right, or from right to left?
Additional question: Do you think you could become just as speedy the dots-and-boxes way as you currently are with the traditional approach?

I4S10-image40

All correct approaches to mathematics are correct, and it is just a matter of style as to which approach you like best for subtraction. The traditional algorithm has you work from right to left and do all the unexplosions as you go along. The dots-and-boxes approach has you “just do it!” and conduct all the unexplosions at the end. Both methods are fine and correct.

Antidotia
Vision byPowered by
Contact GMP:
  • The Global Math Project on Twitter
  • The Global Math Project on Facebook
  • Contact The Global Math Project
Contact BM:
  • Buzzmath on Twitter
  • Buzzmath on Facebook
  • Visit Buzzmath's Website
  • Read Buzzmath's blog!